The Madoka tv series had a great ending. The story was about Homura's friendship with Madoka and in the end she became god and freed the magical girls from the cycle of becoming witches.
THE GOOD
- Homura vs Mami fight. No idea why Homura's time stop doesn't work on her but whatever.
- Elements of the matrix story as the girls fight nightmares and uh do a cake ritual except the ending.
THE BAD
- The whole movie is an elaborate plot by the incubators but its just an excuse for Homura to become the devil and allow Madoka to return to and make them enemies.
Did I miss the part where Madoka is suffering everyday as a god? Was she getting totured everyday ala Angel season 5?
Nope, Homura's love/friendship for Madoka gets twisted.
THE UGLY
The witch that bit Mami's head off becomes her pet Bebe and turns out to be the new magical girl for is there for to be a red herring?
SUMMARY
Pointless continuation. Homura's motivation is so meh and they've changed the heart of the story in the series to a meaningless one. I'm expecting a fourth movie with Homura telling Madoka that they will become enemies one day but I don't care.